
Redistricting sounds like a dry, once a decade exercise in drawing lines on a map. In practice it is one of the more consequential and least understood parts of American elections, and a lot of what people assume about it is wrong. Here are five common myths.
Myth: If a map is drawn specifically to help one political party, federal courts can strike it down
The Supreme Court closed that door in 2019 in Rucho v. Common Cause, ruling that partisan gerrymandering claims present a political question federal courts cannot resolve, even while acknowledging the practice is inconsistent with democratic principles. That ruling did not make partisan gerrymandering legal everywhere. It just means the only remaining paths to challenge it are a state’s own constitution, where one exists and where state courts are willing to enforce it, or a federal law Congress has not yet managed to pass. A 2022 attempt at exactly that kind of federal law, the Freedom to Vote Act, passed the House and then fell two votes short in the Senate.
Myth: You can usually spot a gerrymander because the district looks weirdly shaped
Shape is not actually the tell. Mapmakers use two main techniques, packing disfavored voters into as few districts as possible so their influence is wasted on lopsided wins, or cracking them apart across several districts so they never add up to a majority anywhere. Either technique can produce a perfectly normal looking map. North Carolina’s congressional map has been described as fairly neat looking while still giving one party a near certain hold on ten of its fourteen seats. The practice itself predates the country’s name for it. Patrick Henry is said to have tried to draw Virginia’s first congressional districts specifically to keep his rival James Madison out of a seat, decades before Elbridge Gerry lent his name to the term.
Myth: Districts just naturally end up different sizes because of how population is spread out
This used to be true in practice, and courts made it stop being true as a matter of law. Baker v. Carr opened the door in 1962 to federal courts reviewing how states drew districts, after Tennessee had gone 60 years without redrawing its legislative map despite major population shifts. Wesberry v. Sanders and Reynolds v. Sims followed in 1964, requiring roughly equal population across congressional and state legislative districts alike. Alabama had not redrawn its own legislative map since 1901. Afterward, states everywhere had to redraw, not because the Constitution had changed, but because the Court said equal population had been the requirement the whole time.
Myth: Maps only get redrawn once a decade, right after the census
Mid decade redistricting is legal and has become increasingly common. A separate Supreme Court ruling, LULAC v. Perry, effectively permitted states to redraw their maps for partisan reasons between censuses. In 2025 alone, Texas redrew its congressional map, and California, Virginia, and Florida each followed with new maps of their own, Virginia’s currently on hold in court while an appeal plays out. Wisconsin’s current congressional map still traces back to lines approved around 2010, and two separate lawsuits over it remain active this year, one of which a three judge panel dismissed in March on the grounds that only the state’s own supreme court has the authority to decide whether those lines should change.
Myth: Once the Supreme Court closes a door, that particular fight is over
Rucho closed the federal courthouse door to partisan gerrymandering claims, not every courthouse door. State constitutions are a separate legal foundation entirely, and several of the active fights happening right now are built on exactly that theory. North Carolina’s state supreme court actually struck down a 2021 congressional map under its own state constitution, only to reverse itself after the court’s composition changed and new justices decided they would no longer police partisan maps at all, after which the legislature promptly redrew the map again. Wisconsin’s pending cases are built the same way, arguing the state’s own constitution, not the federal one, limits how far a legislature can go.
Why this matters to voters
The actual battle over who draws your district, and how far they can go to help their own party, has mostly moved out of federal court and into fifty separate state constitutions, state supreme courts, and legislatures, each with different rules and different appetites for enforcing them. Knowing that the fight continues somewhere even after a Supreme Court ruling sounds like it ended it is the difference between assuming your state’s map is fixed and actually knowing where to look if you want to find out.
CGP Grey — a gerrymandering explainer
References
Democracy Docket, Nine redistricting cases that shaped history
Brennan Center for Justice, Gerrymandering, explained
- Five Myths About Gerrymandering and Who Actually Gets to Stop It - November 19, 2026
- What Actually Happened Tuesday Night: Democrats Retake Both Chambers of Congress - November 5, 2026
- Five Myths About How the Electoral College Actually Works - September 29, 2026
