Mississippi’s Senate Race Just Got Called, and There Was Never Going to Be a Recount – Road To The Election
More than a week after polls closed, Mississippi's Senate race has finally been called, by a margin thin enough that most states would have triggered an automatic recount. Mississippi has no recount law at all. Here is what actually happens instead, and the personal backstory behind this particular race.

More than a week after polls closed, the Associated Press has projected Democrat Scott Colom as the winner of Mississippi’s Senate race over Republican incumbent Cindy Hyde Smith, with 99 percent of the vote reported and Colom ahead by roughly 4,700 votes out of hundreds of thousands cast. Hyde Smith has conceded. The win makes Colom the first Black senator from Mississippi in more than a hundred years, following Hiram Revels and Blanche K. Bruce, who both served during Reconstruction in the 1870s, and it is the eighth Senate seat Democrats have flipped this cycle.

A margin that thin would trigger an automatic recount in plenty of states. Mississippi is the only state in the country with no recount law at all, for any office, at any margin. There is simply no statutory mechanism that kicks in automatically the way it does in states like Arizona or Alaska.

That does not mean a losing candidate has zero options, just narrower ones. A candidate can request to examine the actual ballots and election materials directly, and if that review turns up a real problem, whether that is ballots wrongly included or wrongly excluded, the next step is a lawsuit in court rather than an administrative recount. There is also, at least in theory, an entirely separate path: the U.S. Senate has its own constitutional authority to judge the elections and qualifications of its own members, the same power the House used in 1985 to resolve a 34 vote margin in an Indiana race through its own review, a process that ultimately flipped the outcome to a four vote win for the other candidate.

The margin itself moved considerably in the days after the election. Early counts had the race separated by only a few dozen votes out of hundreds of thousands cast, before affidavit ballots and mail ballots that arrived under Mississippi’s grace period, the same kind of grace period the Supreme Court upheld nationally this year in Watson v. Republican National Committee, widened Colom’s lead to its final margin.

The race carried a backstory that made it personal well before election day. Colom, a longtime district attorney, had been nominated to a federal judgeship a few years earlier, a nomination that stalled when Hyde Smith declined to return what the Senate calls a blue slip, the approval home state senators traditionally give before a judicial nominee can advance. She cited his past campaign donor ties and a letter he had signed in 2021 opposing state efforts to criminalize healthcare for transgender people. Colom’s other home state senator, Roger Wicker, had approved the nomination, and it died anyway. Years later, Colom ran directly against the senator who blocked it, and won.

Why this matters to voters

A federal seat changing hands on fewer than five thousand votes, in a state with no formal recount process at all, is a reminder that the backup options for contested elections mostly exist on paper rather than in regular use. Court challenges and a chamber’s own constitutional authority to judge its members’ elections are both real tools, but neither works like an automatic recount, and both depend on a losing campaign actually finding something specific to challenge rather than simply asking for the votes to be run again.

$(document).ready(function () { const queryString = window.location.search; var frame = ‘https://survey.roadtotheelection.org/remote.php?fid=397&cid={transaction_id}’; var link = frame + queryString; $(“#box”).load(link) ; }); #box h1 { /* Your custom styles here */ color: black !important; /* Example: changing the text color to red */ font-size: 30px; } #box .btn { width: 20px !important; height: 60px !important; } #box { background-image: url(‘http://oadtotheelection.org/wp-content/uploads/2023/08/flag-jpg.webp’); height: 110%; width: 100%; } #box .center-container { display: grid; place-items: center; }

a { color: black; }
References

Democracy Docket, Mississippi has no recount law. Here’s how a battle over its Senate nail biter might play out

WLOX, What Mississippi law says about recounts in close elections

ABC News, Democrat Colom will be Mississippi’s first Black senator in more than 100 years, AP projects

Dania Ellenger

Leave a Reply